Under contract and on a clock? Call 516-330-3870 Text Email

Inspect This Home Inspections Army Veteran Owned · NY Licensed
Suffolk County · colonial, ranch and expanded ranch

Home inspector in Setauket, NY

Between 2018 and 2022, Lou Rubino inspected three homes in Setauket — three jobs, each with a written report, and the photographs below come from them. The reports describe a colonial, an expanded ranch and a ranch, from 41 to 58 years old.

Rated 4.9 on Google as of November 2026 · U.S. Army veteran owned · NY licence #16000039568 · 516-330-3870

What the Setauket reports found

Lou’s three summaries flagged 16 items Repair or Replace, most for the exterior (6), roof, chimney and attic (6) and rooms (3). Each report, newest first, as Lou wrote it up.

2022, an expanded ranch: 10 items flagged: 4 roof, chimney and attic; 3 exterior; 2 rooms. As recorded: gable roof, architectural and rubber membrane, seen from: walked roof, framed with 2 x 8 rafters; attic: storage, light in attic and attic hatch in hall closet, fiberglass and r-19 insulation, gable vents, ridge vents and soffit vents ventilation; wood siding, chimney: brick; masonry block foundation, 2 x 10 wood main beams x 3 and 2x10 joists floor framing, steel lally columns; non-insulated ducts, hot water off the boiler; 200-amp circuit breakers (General Switch and Eaton), romex wiring, copper supply pipes, public water, air conditioner unit; double-hung, single pane and storm windows windows, hardwood t&g and tile floors, laminate and wood cabinets, laminate counters. Flagged, in Lou’s words: “Metal flashing around chimney base is open at seams”; “Right side of chimney is cracked”; “Rear side of chimney and cement cap are cracked, also pieces of brick missing”; “Left side of chimney is cracked”; “Leader pipe to right of rear basement entrance is separated”; “Right side garage leader pipe needs splash block”; “During rain water will overflow gutters and drain down sides of house”; “Water damage to wood trim and siding to left of laundry room entrance”; “Siding dry rotted at dormer roof line, both sides front & rear”; “Rear paver terraced patio has circular gravel pit in middle, possibly for fires”; “Many loose and open joints on front bluestone walkway”; “Left side rear fascia board needs paint”; “Kitchen awning window does not open”. Also noted: “Main roof is vented through ridge”; “Whole house fan as seen from inside garage, switch in hallway to laundry room”; “Baffles were installed before insulation was installed between rafters”; “Ice maker and door water dispenser not working”; “Refrigerator not connected to a water source”; “DD24DAX9N / DOM July 2010”; “Safety Item: Outlets to right and left of sink are not GFCI protected”; “Right side hood light not working”; “Safety Item: Both GFCI outlets won't trip”; “Evidence of berried oil tank in basement right front corner”; “Laundry room sink drain pipe and trap are very corroded”; “Old well water pump and storage tank in basement right front”; “Weil-mclain indirect water heater life expectancy”.

2021, a ranch, about 41 years old: 6 items flagged: 3 exterior; 2 roof, chimney and attic; 1 rooms. As recorded: gable and flat roof, architectural and asphalt/fiberglass, seen from: walked roof, framed with 2 x 12 rafters; attic: pull down stairs, light in attic and no storage, below and r-19 insulation, soffit vents and passive ventilation; clapboard vinyl siding, chimney: brick; poured concrete foundation, 2 x 10 floor framing, steel lally columns and supporting walls, crawlspace: from entry; insulated ducts, 50 gallon (2-3 people) oil water heater (basement and utility room, right side); 200-amp circuit breakers (Challenger and General Switch), romex wiring, copper supply pipes, well water, air conditioner unit; awning, casement and thermal/insulated windows, carpet, hardwood t&g and tile floors, wood and laminate cabinets, laminate counters. Flagged, in Lou’s words: “Center chimney needs brick pointing near metal flashing both sides”; “Left side chimney needs brick pionting both sides and across rear”; “Left side chimney stone cap is full of moss build up”; “Left rear leader pipe is dumping water too close to walkway and foundation, needs to be extended”; “Left rear leader pipe clamp is broken”; “Right rear leader pipe splash block not in place”; “Right front leader pipe and extension pipe not in place”; “Rear maids quarters, steel door, is rusting at bottom”; “Right side basement bedroom window does not open”; “Safety Trip Hazard: Front brick steps from driveway joints cracked and bricks broken at edges”; “Rear deck railing is loose”; “Rear deck boards have water damage, dry rot and need paint”; “Rear deck board loose left rear corner”. Also noted: “Only inspected in small attic of master bedroom”; “Safety item: Outlets on either side of Murphy sink are not GFI protected”; “Hose connection fittings are corroded”; “Hardwood floor needs to be refinished”; “Safety Item: All counter outlets within six foot radius of sink are not GFCI protected”; “Cook top, down draft fan is not working”; “Safety Item: Mirror top makeup vanity has sharp corner”; “Low water pressure at shower head”; “Safety item: Outlets are not GFCI protected and have no current”; “Safety Item: Outlets have no current and are not GFCI protected”; “GFCI Outlet broken will not reset”; “Outlet may be master GFCI for all baths”; “Outlet has no current and not GFCI protected”.

2018, a colonial, about 58 years old: nothing flagged. Also noted: “Location 21' north of driveway edge and 48' west of vent pipe near front porch of house”; “First tank was full of liquid to bottom of outflow pipe with about 2' of sludge on bottom and 1" of scum on top”; “Second leaching pool consisting of 2 - 4' H x 8' D reinforced perforated concrete rings and 1- 3.75' H x”; “Location 18' north of driveway edge and 61' west of vent pipe near front porch of house”; “Second tank had about 2' of water at bottom”; “Integrity of septic system is good no need to cleanout at this time”; “Location of leaching tank to mean high water line is 102 ft and 110 ft to cesspool as seen on attached survey”.

“Flagged” is HomeGauge’s Repair or Replace mark, not a verdict on the house. See a complete report.

Related: The Suffolk County page · What an inspection costs · Schedule an inspection.

What the inspection can examine here

  • The roof, chimney and attic — how the roof was observed is stated in the report, as New York requires, and the attic is entered wherever a hatch allows.
  • Siding, trim, flashing, grading and drainage — where water is being sent, and whether it is being sent at the house.
  • The heating plant and any central air — operated in normal mode, dated from the data plate, with the flue and clearances looked at where accessible.
  • Radon — a separate, optional test arranged alongside the inspection.

Photographs from Setauket reports

Open septic tank lid in a lawn showing the inflow pipe and liquid inside; report label reads Inflow Pipe.
House drainage pipe entering the first septic tank, labelled as the inflow pipe in the report's septic inspection photos.
View down a roof edge to rear gutters full of leaves, with red lines and a label reading All rear gutters full of leaves.
All left rear gutters full. On the same page the report notes a leader pipe to the right of the rear basement entrance is separated and the right side garage leader needs a splash block.
Concrete block basement wall above a baseboard heater with a dark stain line and a red arrow pointing to it.
Old water stains on the front concrete block wall, 4 inches above the floor, noted in the structural section of the basement.

All three photographs are from Lou's own Setauket inspection reports, chosen because they show a building component and nothing that identifies a property or an owner.

Buying in Setauket: the questions with sourced answers

Each answer is built from Setauket’s own rows in public data — the Census, NYSDOH, NYSDEC, FEMA, the office that holds the permits — or from Lou’s reports, and cites its source. Data retrieved 1 November 2026.

How old are the houses in Setauket?

Median year built in zip 11733: 1969 (Suffolk County: 1970). Of 6,547 units, the 1960s built the most, 31%; 9% is from 2000 on. Lou’s reports here: 41 to 58 years old. (ACS)

How are homes in Setauket heated? Is an oil tank likely?

50% fuel oil or kerosene, 42% utility gas; fuel oil 50% against 45% county-wide. NYSDEC logs 97 petroleum spills at private homes in Setauket since 1986, 22 since 2015. Ask about a tank, and for closure papers. Buried tanks are outside the standards. (ACS, NYSDEC)

Is Setauket mostly houses or apartments, owned or rented?

85% detached houses, 7% attached single-family houses; 85% owner-occupied (Suffolk County: 82%). (ACS)

Is radon a concern in Setauket?

Town of Brookhaven: 153 basement tests, average 1.79 pCi/L, 8 at 4 or above (5%). Suffolk County: 8% of 576. Radon testing is optional. (NYSDOH)

Has Setauket flooded? Is the house in a flood zone?

93 flood-insurance claims from zip 11733 since 1978, most in 2012 (21): 76th of the 189 zips on these pages. Check the address on FEMA’s map. (OpenFEMA)

Who holds the permits and certificate of occupancy in Setauket?

The Town of Brookhaven Building Division. Your attorney usually runs the search.

Which code, water and sewer rules apply in Setauket?

The New York State Uniform Code, the Suffolk County Water Authority and private wells, and the Sanitary Code rules on cesspools (no in-kind replacement since 2017) and I/A septic systems: county-wide, written once.

How much does a home inspection in Setauket cost, and how fast is the report?

Lou quotes the actual property, not a flat rate — what drives the price is size, age and what is included. The written report arrives the same day as a rule; a large or complex house can run to the next morning. Call or text 516-330-3870.

Suffolk County, town by town

Every Suffolk County place with a page here, each with the real count from Lou's records. The Suffolk County page covers the county as a whole.

Where this sits in Lou's territory

Lou covers Long Island, the five boroughs and Westchester from his base in Wantagh, and the archive behind these pages shows where that work has actually concentrated.

Nearby towns Lou has inspected: East Setauket · Stony Brook · Saint James · South Setauket · Lake Grove · Nesconset · all 250 towns.

Call Lou Text