Under contract and on a clock? Call 516-330-3870 Text Email

Inspect This Home Inspections Army Veteran Owned · NY Licensed
Suffolk County · colonials and expanded ranch

Home inspector in East Setauket, NY

Between 2020 and 2021, Lou Rubino inspected three homes in East Setauket — three jobs, each with a written report, and the photographs below come from them. The reports describe two colonials and an expanded ranch, from 32 to 33 years old.

Rated 4.9 on Google as of November 2026 · U.S. Army veteran owned · NY licence #16000039568 · 516-330-3870

What the East Setauket reports found

Lou’s three summaries flagged 33 items Repair or Replace, most for the exterior (11), roof, chimney and attic (7) and rooms (6). Each report, newest first, as Lou wrote it up.

2021, an expanded ranch: 12 items flagged: 4 roof, chimney and attic; 4 exterior; 2 rooms. As recorded: gable roof, 3-tab fiberglass and asphalt/fiberglass, seen from: walked roof, framed with engineered wood trusses; attic: light in attic and no storage, fiberglass, below and r-19 insulation, soffit vents and passive ventilation; tongue and groove cedar siding, chimney: brick; poured concrete foundation, 2 x 8 and 2"x 12" x 2 wood main beams floor framing, steel lally columns; partially insulated ducts, 40 gallon (1-2 people) electric water heater (basement and utility area); 200-amp circuit breakers (Square D), romex wiring, copper supply pipes, public water, air conditioner unit; casement and thermal/insulated windows, carpet, hardwood t&g and tile floors, laminate cabinets, laminate counters. Flagged, in Lou’s words: “Very poor shingle repair job around skylight and colors don't match”; “Two shingle missing left rear”; “Loss of mineral on edges of shingle, right rear”; “One shingle missing right rear”; “Shingle raised up at edge near, right rear deck”; “Boiler chimney needs pointing near top and cement cap is cracked”; “Fireplace chimney cement cap is cracked”; “Most common cause of damp basements is improper disposal of roof water”; “Leader and gutter system needed on left front roof”; “Daylight coming through rear gable”; “Wood siding needs to be cleaned and waterproofed or painted”; “Rear deck, rear steps, third tread is worn”; “Steps and railing need waterproofing or paint”. Also noted: “Oven is over 30 years old”; “Oven clock does not operate”; “Parts not available for repairs”; “Water heater is 15 years old average life of a tank water heater is 13 years”; “Return vent is located in entry foyer and not connected with ductwork to air handler”; “Air handler is pulling a mix of basement and house air”; “Filter on top on unit is filthy”; “Metal duct work above air handler is not insulated”; “Condensate pump is full of debris and dirt”; “Bedrooms do not have returns and doors should be left open for free flow of air”.

2021, a colonial, about 32 years old: 14 items flagged: 5 exterior; 4 rooms; 3 kitchen. As recorded: gable roof, architectural and asphalt/fiberglass, seen from: ground, framed with 2 x 10 rafters; attic: light in attic and no storage, fiberglass and r-30 or better insulation, gable vents, soffit vents and passive ventilation; brick and clapboard vinyl and full brick siding, chimney: brick; poured concrete foundation, 2 x12 and two 2"x12"x3 each floor framing, steel lally columns, crawlspace: crawled; partially insulated ducts, 32 gallon (small) fuel oil water heater (basement); 200-amp circuit breakers (General Electric), romex wiring, copper supply pipes, public water, air conditioner unit; double-hung and thermal/insulated windows, carpet, hardwood t&g and tile floors, wood cabinets, granite counters. Flagged, in Lou’s words: “In attic insulation missing from areas between joists and studs”; “Recessed lighting can be a source of draft”; “Slot in vinyl siding left side from removed in ground oil tank vent pipe”; “Lentil iron is rust-jacking brickwork over garage front and dinning room picture windows”; “Rear kitchen entrance door difficult to open, hits saddle”; “Front entrance door difficult to open, hits saddle”; “Rear den doors difficult to open, hits saddles”; “Left side basement window well, corrugated steel soil retainer,is rusted through”; “Right rear wood steps railing is loose”; “Left rear wood steps railing is loose”; “Many deck boards uneven, large spaces and water damaged (As seen in MLS photo)”; “Rear entrance doorway to kitchen sheetrock is cracked”; “Sheetrock tape peeling at corners in kitchen”. Also noted: “Roof covered in snow and ice”; “Fuel oil fill and vent pipe on left rear exterior wall”; “Keep area free of snow for easy fuel delivery”; “Evidence of berried oil tank”; “Oil tank in basement 319 gal, 12 gauge steel, DOM 2008”; “Master GFCI for all bathrooms in bedroom bath front”; “Main breaker panel is in garage left rear”; “Copper heat pipes in basement and crawl space are not insulated”; “Metal ductwork in basement and attic is not insulated”; “Metal ductwork at end of run in crawl space needs hanger strap”.

2020, a colonial, about 33 years old: 7 items flagged: 2 roof, chimney and attic; 2 exterior; 1 garage. As recorded: gable roof, architectural and asphalt/fiberglass, seen from: walked, framed with 2 x 8 rafters; attic: no storage, r-19 insulation, gable vents, ridge vents and passive ventilation; clapboard vinyl siding, chimney: brick; poured concrete foundation, 2 x 10 and 2"x 12"x 3ea main wood beam floor framing, steel lally columns; hydronic heat on oil, hot water off the boiler; 200-amp circuit breakers (General Switch), romex wiring, copper supply pipes, public water, air conditioner unit; double-hung, thermal/insulated and awning windows, hardwood t&g, carpet and tile floors, wood cabinets, quartz counters. Flagged, in Lou’s words: “Chimney cap is in good condition”; “Upper leader pipes in rear need to be extended to lower gutters”; “Rear lower roof over window seat needs leader and gutter system”; “Gutter guard in front has caved into gutter in three places, and gutter full of debris”; “Leader pipe left front half out of drain pipe”; “Right rear deck railing is loose needs to be secured to house”; “Bottom 2x4 rail is rotted right rear middle”; “Whole yard is pitched to, left rear side entrance of deck”; “Heavy puddling of water during rain”; “Right rear tree branches hitting roof”; “Safety item: Right side door lift springs do not have safety cables”; “Craftsman garage door opener doesn't work consistently”; “Switch appears to be faulty”. Also noted: “Rear hose bib is under loose deck board near house”; “Partially inspected, garage cluttered with storage”; “Main GFCI in 2nd floor, hall bath”; “Heat pipes in boiler room need to be insulated”; “Metal ductwork in closets needs to be insulated”; “Second floor radiators did not get hot, may be air bound from leaking bleeder valve”.

“Flagged” is HomeGauge’s Repair or Replace mark, not a verdict on the house. See a complete report.

Related: The Suffolk County page · What an inspection costs · Schedule an inspection.

What the inspection can examine here

  • Kitchen plumbing, GFCI protection and the built-in appliances, run through their normal cycles.
  • The roof, chimney and attic — how the roof was observed is stated in the report, as New York requires, and the attic is entered wherever a hatch allows.
  • Walls, ceilings, floors, windows and doors room by room — the evidence of movement or moisture, not the decoration.
  • Radon — a separate, optional test arranged alongside the inspection.

Photographs from East Setauket reports

Concrete chimney foundation below brick with red dashed lines tracing cracks, red arrow at the top.
Chimney foundation cracked in two places at the right rear, with the cracks traced on the photo.

The photograph is from Lou's own East Setauket inspection report, chosen because it shows a building component and nothing that identifies a property or an owner.

Buying in East Setauket: the questions with sourced answers

Each answer is built from East Setauket’s own rows in public data — the Census, NYSDOH, NYSDEC, FEMA, the office that holds the permits — or from Lou’s reports, and cites its source. Data retrieved 1 November 2026.

How old are the houses in East Setauket?

Median year built in zip 11733: 1969 (Suffolk County: 1970). Of 6,547 units, the 1960s built the most, 31%; 9% is from 2000 on. Lou’s reports here: 32 to 33 years old. (ACS)

How are homes in East Setauket heated? Is an oil tank likely?

50% fuel oil or kerosene, 42% utility gas; fuel oil 50% against 45% county-wide. NYSDEC logs 91 petroleum spills at private homes in East Setauket since 1986, 32 since 2015. Ask about a tank, and for closure papers. Buried tanks are outside the standards. (ACS, NYSDEC)

Is East Setauket mostly houses or apartments, owned or rented?

85% detached houses, 7% attached single-family houses; 85% owner-occupied (Suffolk County: 82%). (ACS)

Is radon a concern in East Setauket?

Town of Brookhaven: 153 basement tests, average 1.79 pCi/L, 8 at 4 or above (5%). Suffolk County: 8% of 576. Radon testing is optional. (NYSDOH)

Has East Setauket flooded? Is the house in a flood zone?

93 flood-insurance claims from zip 11733 since 1978, most in 2012 (21): 76th of the 189 zips on these pages. Check the address on FEMA’s map. (OpenFEMA)

Who holds the permits and certificate of occupancy in East Setauket?

The Town of Brookhaven Building Division. Your attorney usually runs the search.

Which code, water and sewer rules apply in East Setauket?

The New York State Uniform Code, the Suffolk County Water Authority and private wells, and the Sanitary Code rules on cesspools (no in-kind replacement since 2017) and I/A septic systems: county-wide, written once.

How much does a home inspection in East Setauket cost, and how fast is the report?

Lou quotes the actual property, not a flat rate — what drives the price is size, age and what is included. The written report arrives the same day as a rule; a large or complex house can run to the next morning. Call or text 516-330-3870.

Suffolk County, town by town

Every Suffolk County place with a page here, each with the real count from Lou's records. The Suffolk County page covers the county as a whole.

Where this sits in Lou's territory

Lou covers Long Island, the five boroughs and Westchester from his base in Wantagh, and the archive behind these pages shows where that work has actually concentrated.

Nearby towns Lou has inspected: Setauket · Stony Brook · Saint James · South Setauket · Lake Grove · Nesconset · all 250 towns.

Call Lou Text